
A federal appeals court has blocked the Pentagon from discharging 27 transgender service members while a legal challenge to President Donald Trump’s military policy continues, delivering another judicial setback to the administration.
On Tuesday, November 17, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected the administration’s request to suspend an earlier ruling that found the Pentagon’s transgender military restrictions were likely unlawful.
The 2-1 decision allows an injunction protecting the affected service members to take effect immediately while the Trump administration pursues further appeals, including a possible review by the U.S. Supreme Court.
The ruling applies specifically to the 27 current service members involved in the lawsuit. It does not overturn the administration’s broader policy or authorize new transgender recruits to enlist.
The decision represents an important development in the continuing legal battle over Trump’s efforts to restrict transgender military service.
Appeals court rejects Pentagon’s request
The Trump administration had asked the appeals court to put its June 1 decision on hold while it prepared to petition the Supreme Court.
Federal attorneys argued that allowing the earlier ruling to take effect would interfere with the government’s authority to establish military personnel standards.
The appeals court rejected that argument.
Judge Robert Wilkins, who authored the majority opinion, said the government had failed to demonstrate that allowing the 27 service members to remain in uniform would cause irreparable harm or threaten national security.
Judge Judith Rogers joined the decision to deny the administration’s request, while Judge Justin Walker dissented and supported granting the government’s motion.
Wilkins also rejected the administration’s argument that a recent Supreme Court decision involving transgender students undermined the appeals court’s earlier ruling.
The majority emphasized that the Pentagon’s policy reaches beyond individuals diagnosed with gender dysphoria, extending to people who have attempted to transition, including through changes in clothing or pronouns.
The court questioned whether such broad restrictions could be justified through legitimate military readiness concerns.
27 service members protected by the ruling
The injunction covers 27 transgender military personnel who collectively have more than 130 years of military service and have received more than 80 commendations, according to attorneys representing the plaintiffs.
The government has acknowledged that the affected service members meet the military’s professional and performance standards.
Despite their records, several had been placed on administrative leave, while others faced potential separation proceedings under the Pentagon’s policy.
The plaintiffs argued that removing experienced personnel who had demonstrated their ability to meet military requirements would undermine military readiness rather than strengthen it.
The National Center for LGBTQ Rights and GLAD Law, which represent the service members, welcomed the appeals court’s decision.
Shannon Minter, legal director of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, said the government had failed to identify evidence justifying the removal of the affected troops.
Jennifer Levi of GLAD Law also criticized the policy, arguing that it unfairly targets an entire group of service members.
The administration has not abandoned its position and continues to defend the restrictions as a matter of military personnel policy.
Trump’s executive order triggered legal battle
The dispute began in January 2025, when Trump signed an executive order directing the Pentagon to restrict transgender military service.
The order argued that identifying as transgender and having gender dysphoria conflicted with the administration’s standards for military readiness, discipline, cohesion and effectiveness.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth subsequently implemented a policy that presumptively disqualified individuals diagnosed with gender dysphoria from military service.
The administration maintained that the restrictions were necessary to preserve military effectiveness and ensure that personnel meet consistent standards.
The policy immediately faced legal challenges from transgender service members and individuals seeking to enlist.
In March 2025, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued an injunction blocking the policy in a lawsuit brought by affected service members. The Trump administration appealed, and the D.C. Circuit subsequently narrowed the protections, distinguishing between individuals already serving and those attempting to join.
The Supreme Court later allowed the administration to begin enforcing the broader ban while litigation continued in a separate case.
The latest appeals court decision restores protections for the 27 current service members covered by the Talbott v. United States lawsuit, but leaves the broader restrictions in place.
Supreme Court showdown could be next
The Trump administration is continuing its effort to obtain Supreme Court review of the June appeals court decision.
The Justice Department’s petition remains pending, creating the possibility that the nation’s highest court will once again consider the administration’s authority to restrict transgender military service.
The legal dispute raises broader constitutional questions involving executive authority, equal protection and the military’s power to establish eligibility standards.
The administration argues that military personnel policies deserve substantial deference from the courts because decisions involving readiness and operational effectiveness fall within the authority of the executive branch.
Opponents of the restrictions argue that the government cannot exclude otherwise qualified service members based on broad assumptions about gender identity without demonstrating a legitimate justification.
A trial in the underlying district court case is scheduled for January 2027.
What the ruling means for the military
Tuesday’s decision does not end Trump’s transgender military policy. Instead, it establishes an important legal distinction between the 27 service members protected by the injunction and other individuals affected by the administration’s restrictions.
For the protected plaintiffs, the military cannot proceed with discharges under the challenged policy while the injunction remains in effect.
However, transgender individuals seeking to enlist are not covered by the restored protection and remain subject to the administration’s restrictions.
The case is likely to remain a major legal and political issue as the administration continues defending its military personnel policies.
With the Supreme Court potentially preparing to review the dispute, the outcome could have lasting consequences for military recruitment, personnel standards and the constitutional limits of presidential authority.
For now, the 27 service members at the center of the lawsuit can continue serving as their legal challenge moves forward.

