A federal appeals court delivered a significant victory on Thursday to two northern Virginia school systems, reinstating their lawsuits against the U.S. Department of Education regarding the defense of their transgender student policies.
The ruling clears a path for the Fairfax and Arlington County school boards to proceed with their legal challenge in regular federal courts, overturning a lower court’s decision that had previously dismissed the cases for lack of jurisdiction.
The ongoing legal battle centers around the school districts’ refusal to amend their internal guidelines regarding facility access and protections for transgender students. In response to the districts’ refusal to change the policies, the Department of Education moved to freeze federal funding for the schools, prompting the lawsuits.
The school boards argue that the funding freeze is an unlawful retaliatory action that violates Title IX protections and constitutional standards.
The majority of the appeals court judges agreed that dismissing the lawsuits outright for lack of jurisdiction was an error, allowing the cases to proceed on their merits in the federal system. The panel noted, however, that it has not yet assessed or ruled on the underlying merits of the lawsuits themselves.
The court’s decision was not unanimous. Judge Julius Richardson dissented from his colleagues, arguing that the core of the districts’ claims is financial in nature—amounting to contract payment disputes—and should therefore be heard by the U.S. Court of Federal Claims rather than regular federal district courts.
The ruling breathes new life into a highly watched case that has sweeping implications for how Title IX protections are interpreted and enforced regarding gender identity at the local public school level.


