A federal appeals court ruled on Friday that President Donald Trump acted unlawfully when he federalized and deployed the National Guard to Los Angeles, California, amid regional protests. In a 2-1 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit upheld a lower court’s injunction, finding that the administration failed to meet the statutory requirements necessary to wrest control of the troops from state authorities.
Writing for the majority, Judge Jennifer Sung concluded that the federal government had not satisfied the legal thresholds required to deploy the Guard over the objections of Governor Gavin Newsom. The panel rejected the administration’s assertion that local demonstrations protesting federal immigration policies constituted a “rebellion” beyond the capacity of local law enforcement to manage. Trump-nominated Judge Mark Bennett dissented, arguing that the panel should not have ruled on the case because the administration had attempted to drop its appeal of the preliminary injunction.
California officials immediately celebrated the ruling as a significant victory for state sovereignty and the 10th Amendment. Governor Newsom praised the decision as a “critical safeguard” ahead of the November elections, stating that it sets a firm legal boundary against utilizing the military for domestic civilian issues.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta echoed the governor’s sentiments, characterizing the unilateral deployment as “a clear example of federal overreach.” The Justice Department has not yet issued a public comment on whether it plans to appeal the decision further.


