The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals appeared skeptical during a rare Sunday hearing regarding the Justice Department’s urgent request to force California to set aside 20,000 mail-in ballots. According to the Times of India, the Trump administration suspects these ballots belong to noncitizens, but the appellate judges sharply questioned the legal basis and timing of the federal intervention.
Justice Department attorney Matthew Donnelly argued that an emergency injunction was necessary to segregate the ballots and prevent irreparable harm to the election’s integrity. However, the three-judge panel raised significant constitutional concerns. Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, questioned if the DOJ’s demand violated the U.S. Constitution’s Elections Clause, which gives states the authority to administer their own elections. Meanwhile, Judge Gabriel Sanchez questioned the court’s authority to intervene before a lower court could even issue a ruling.
California officials and attorneys representing Los Angeles County fiercely disputed the DOJ’s claims, arguing that the federal government’s list of suspected noncitizens is highly flawed. An initial review of the federal list reportedly found inactive voters, canceled registrations, and individuals who appeared to have been born in the United States. State attorneys warned that enforcing the DOJ’s request would create massive administrative burdens and risk disenfranchising eligible voters.
The appeals court promised to deliver a decision as quickly as possible. If the 9th Circuit rejects the federal government’s emergency appeal, the case will return to U.S. District Judge David O. Carter for a previously scheduled hearing on Tuesday, October 27, just one week before the highly contested November 3 midterm elections.


