A U.S. appeals court threw out an order on Friday that would have allowed thousands of Tesla customers in California to pursue a class-action lawsuit against the electric vehicle manufacturer over its “Full Self-Driving” (FSD) claims.
In its decision, a three-judge panel for the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals determined that the lawsuit could not proceed as a class action because there were too many individualized questions regarding what each buyer actually saw and relied upon before purchasing their vehicle.
The ruling is a significant, albeit potentially temporary, victory for Tesla. It effectively vacates orders from a California district judge last year that had certified three sets of classes. As a result, the thousands of California buyers who were previously grouped together cannot currently pursue their claims jointly in a single, massive case.
The plaintiffs in the underlying lawsuit allege false advertising, contending that Tesla misrepresented the hardware capabilities of its vehicles and convinced customers to pay premium prices for self-driving software that ultimately does not work as promised. In the initial ruling, U.S. District Judge Rita Lin found that prospective buyers were likely exposed to Tesla’s claims on its website that vehicles sold from October 2016 onward contained the necessary hardware for full self-driving capabilities.
However, appellate judges Ronald Gould, Jay Bybee, and Daniel Bress concluded that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that every class member had been exposed to the allegedly false statements.
Despite Friday’s ruling, the court did not decide on the actual merits of the false advertising claims, and the underlying lawsuit remains pending. Plaintiffs’ attorneys expressed disappointment, stating that the panel failed to fully appreciate the unique circumstances of the case and the central role the hardware claims played in Tesla’s marketing strategy.
Tesla, which has consistently denied the plaintiffs’ claims, was supported in the appeal by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. The powerful business advocacy group argued that allowing the class action to proceed would have threatened businesses with overbroad and costly litigation.


