The Justice Department has formally filed a judicial misconduct complaint against several federal district judges in Minnesota, accusing them of violating ethical duties by speaking to the press.
The unprecedented complaint, announced by Attorney General Todd Blanche on Wednesday, targets Chief Judge Patrick J. Schiltz, Judge John R. Tunheim, and up to five other unnamed judges in the District of Minnesota. The dispute centers on a recent New York Times article concerning “Operation Metro Surge,” a controversial federal immigration enforcement effort in the state.
According to the complaint, which was filed with the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, the DOJ alleges the judges improperly discussed cases that are pending or ongoing, undermining public confidence in an impartial judiciary. During his interview, Judge Schiltz criticized the Trump administration’s disregard for court orders during the immigration crackdown, stating it “created a grave threat to the rule of law”. Judge Tunheim similarly commented on the nature of the arrests, stating the individuals detained were not “dangerous criminals on the street”.
Attorney General Blanche attacked the comments as “blatantly false” and overtly political. The DOJ is demanding that the targeted judges recuse themselves from all civil and criminal cases involving the Department of Homeland Security due to “obvious bias,” a move that would effectively halt a massive portion of federal court proceedings in the state.
While it is highly unusual for active federal judges to grant on-the-record interviews to the press regarding administrative actions, the judges maintained they were not discussing specific, active cases before their courts. However, the Justice Department argues that even broad, politically charged commentary on the administration’s actions violates the judicial code of conduct by creating the perception of partisan bias.
The 8th Circuit’s Judicial Council will now have to review the complaint to determine if disciplinary actions or forced recusals are warranted.


