A federal judge in New Jersey has dismissed a high-profile lawsuit brought by the Department of Justice against a group of pro-Palestinian activists, rejecting the government’s attempt to prosecute the demonstrators under a law traditionally used to protect access to abortion clinics.
U.S. District Judge Katharine Hayden tossed the case on Thursday, determining that the DOJ failed to adequately prove the protesters violated the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act. The legislation was passed in 1994 primarily to prevent anti-abortion extremists from blockading reproductive health centers, though it also contains provisions protecting places of religious worship.
The underlying conflict stemmed from a November 2024 protest outside a synagogue in West Orange, New Jersey. The demonstrators, which included members of American Muslims for Palestine-New Jersey, had gathered to protest an Israeli real estate fair taking place inside the congregation. The government’s complaint alleged that the activists intentionally interfered with religious exercise during the confrontation, which included physical altercations between protesters and attendees of the real estate auction.
However, Judge Hayden ruled that the DOJ’s complaint fell significantly short of establishing that the alleged violence was intended to interfere with religious worship. In her decision, she warned that applying the FACE Act too broadly would run the risk of making “every push, shove, brawl or forceful conduct” at any protest a federal violation.
The judge also noted that the real estate fair itself was the primary target of the demonstration, rather than the religious activities taking place in the synagogue simultaneously.
The DOJ had attempted to cite a 2002 case involving “wanted posters” targeting anti-abortion doctors to bolster its claims, but the court found the comparison unconvincing.
The ruling marks a significant setback for the Trump administration’s Justice Department, which has increasingly sought to deploy the FACE Act in unconventional ways. Civil liberties advocates have closely monitored the case, warning that stretching the bounds of the statute could have severe chilling effects on First Amendment rights and the freedom to protest.
The DOJ now has 30 days to file an amended complaint or abandon the case entirely.


