A federal judge delivered a major legal blow to the Trump administration on Thursday, ordering the White House to immediately restore press credentials for journalists from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico.
U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly, a Trump appointee, issued the temporary restraining order after the three news organizations filed a joint lawsuit earlier this week. The outlets contested President Donald Trump’s September 18 decision to abruptly ban their reporters from the White House grounds, which he announced via social media by accusing them of publishing “fiction and lies.”
The ruling marks a significant victory for press freedom advocates and sets up a protracted legal battle over the executive branch’s authority to dictate media access based on coverage it deems unfavorable.
A Failure of Due Process
During Wednesday’s hearings leading up to the decision, Judge Kelly signaled deep skepticism toward the Justice Department’s defense of the ban.
Government attorneys argued that access to the White House is a “privilege, not a right,” and attempted to justify the sweeping ban on national security grounds, claiming the outlets had published sensitive information and failed to maintain professional decorum.
However, Kelly zeroed in on the Fifth Amendment’s right to due process. Citing decades of legal precedent—most notably the 1977 case Sherrill v. Knight—the judge noted that the White House cannot arbitrarily revoke established press credentials without fair warning and a formal appeals process.
“I think it’s fair to say that the process wasn’t played out here,” Kelly remarked during the hearing. The judge was particularly critical of the fact that the White House only sent the media outlets formal letters outlining the alleged “standards of professionalism” violations after their access had already been revoked.
A Familiar Legal Clash
Theodore Boutrous, the attorney representing the media organizations, successfully argued that the retroactive letters “completely do not reflect what the president himself has said.” Boutrous pointed to Trump’s own social media posts as clear evidence that the ban was rooted in viewpoint discrimination—a blatant violation of the First Amendment—rather than legitimate national security concerns.
This is not the first time Judge Kelly has ruled against the Trump administration in a dispute over media access. In 2018, during the president’s first term, Kelly similarly ordered the White House to restore the press pass of CNN correspondent Jim Acosta after it was abruptly pulled following a contentious press conference.
While Thursday’s order temporarily restores the journalists’ access to the White House, the broader lawsuit regarding the administration’s alleged First Amendment violations will continue to play out in federal court.


