The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Department of Education have accused the University of California, Berkeley School of Law of illegally discriminating against white and Asian applicants in favor of Black and Hispanic prospective students.
In a six-page findings letter issued Wednesday, federal investigators alleged that the prestigious law school violated Title VI of the Civil Rights Act while selecting its incoming classes for 2024 and 2025. The investigation concluded that Berkeley Law deliberately attempted to circumvent the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling in Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), which struck down race-based affirmative action in college admissions, as well as California’s own Proposition 209, which banned the practice in 1996.
“Backdoor” Demographics and Admissions Data
The DOJ letter, spearheaded by Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon, criticized the school’s application materials—specifically essay prompts regarding how an applicant’s “perspective, experience, voice” would contribute to classroom diversity. Investigators characterized these prompts as a “backdoor to solicit applicants’ racial demographics.”
According to the federal analysis of applicant-level data, the school’s admissions models showed “highly statistically significant racial preferences.” In 2025, federal officials stated that Black applicants had 5.8 times higher odds of admission than comparable white applicants with similar undergraduate GPAs and LSAT scores. In the same year, the median LSAT score for admitted Black students was a 167, compared to a 172 for both white and Asian admitted students.
The government also pointed to public statements made by Berkeley Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky. Investigators noted that Chemerinsky has openly stated the school would “aggressively pursue” a diverse student body and cited past remarks where the dean discussed practicing “unstated affirmative action.”
Berkeley Law Denies the Allegations
Dean Chemerinsky firmly pushed back against the federal findings, maintaining that the school’s admissions policies are completely lawful.
“Our admissions policy is clear that race is not considered in any way in admissions decisions,” Chemerinsky said in a statement. “Proposition 209, federal statutes, and the Supreme Court’s decisions do not preclude schools from pursuing diversity so long as they give no preferences based on race. Berkeley Law does not do so.”
The university added that it will “spare no effort to provide ample evidence” proving its compliance with all governing rules and laws.
The DOJ has requested that Berkeley Law enter into a “voluntary resolution agreement” to bring its admissions process into federal compliance. The department warned that it will pursue a lawsuit if a negotiated settlement cannot be reached.


