An Afghan woman accused of supporting an Islamic State-inspired terror plot has been deported from the United States in a landmark legal proceeding. The case marks the first time the Justice Department has successfully utilized the Alien Terrorist Removal Court (ATRC)—an obscure federal tribunal established nearly 30 years ago.
According to the Justice Department, 47-year-old Nazira Haji Zada of Fort Worth, Texas, was deported to Afghanistan after consenting to her removal. While Haji Zada was never criminally charged, federal prosecutors alleged she was the “matriarch” of a radicalized family and supported a foiled plot by her son and son-in-law to carry out an ISIS-inspired mass shooting on Election Day in 2024.
Her son, Abdullah Haji Zada, and son-in-law, Nasir Ahmad Tawhedi, were arrested after attempting to purchase AK-47-style rifles and 500 rounds of ammunition from an undercover FBI agent. Both men subsequently pleaded guilty to terrorism-related charges.
A Long-Dormant Court Reactivated
Instead of pursuing criminal charges against Haji Zada, Attorney General Todd Blanche authorized civil proceedings through the ATRC.
Congress created the five-judge court in 1996 following the Oklahoma City bombing to give the government a streamlined process for deporting noncitizens suspected of terrorism. Crucially, the ATRC allows the Justice Department to use classified intelligence as evidence without fully disclosing it to the defendant, providing only an unclassified summary to protect national security interests. Until now, the court had never heard a case.
Attorney General Blanche praised the outcome, calling the court’s activation a major victory for the country. “This landmark case, resulting in the prompt removal of this alien terrorist to her country of origin, is a win for national security and the rule of law,” Blanche said in a statement, emphasizing that the DOJ will use “every tool at its disposal.”
Due Process Concerns
While Haji Zada ultimately waived her right to challenge her detention and agreed to be deported, her defense team sharply criticized the secretive nature of the proceedings.
Her public defenders argued that withholding roughly half a terabyte of classified supporting documents from the defense severely violated her constitutional rights. In a public statement, her lawyers stressed that Haji Zada’s decision to leave the country “should not be seen as an endorsement of this court’s legitimacy.”
“Dragging lawful permanent residents into court but refusing to show them or their attorneys the evidence that will be used against them is a plain violation of due process,” her defense team stated, predicting that the court’s framework would eventually be struck down as unconstitutional.
Court filings surrounding the deportation, including the removal order signed by Chief Judge Joan Ericksen in August, were kept under seal until Haji Zada safely arrived at her final destination.


