A South Florida man was arrested for allegedly mailing a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman with a deadly peanut allergy, turning a bitter divorce dispute into a potentially fatal encounter.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested on November 13 by the Plantation Police Department and charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence. According to arrest affidavits, the incident traces back to August 14, 2025, when the victim discovered a greasy blue envelope in her driveway. Inside, she found a greeting card covered in a brown substance she quickly identified as peanut butter.
Despite washing her hands immediately, the woman—who is the best friend of Cancellare’s ex-wife—suffered an allergic reaction that included hives and tingling in her arms that lasted for six hours. Police noted that her allergy is so severe that airborne particles or simple touch could trigger a life-threatening reaction requiring immediate medical intervention.
Authorities say Cancellare and the victim had known each other for over 20 years, and he was fully aware of the severity of her allergy, having witnessed her strict precautions at gatherings. Investigators believe the motive stemmed from his contentious divorce, as Cancellare had allegedly told acquaintances he wanted to harm people connected to the separation, blaming the victim for the split.
Detectives cracked the case by tracing two “Forever” stamps on the blue envelope to a U.S. Postal Service self-service kiosk in Davie, Florida. Purchase records showed the stamps were bought using Cancellare’s Visa card on August 8, 2025, and a photograph taken by the kiosk captured a man in sunglasses whom the victim and others easily identified as Cancellare.
He was booked into the Broward Sheriff’s Office main jail with his bond set at $20,000.


