Former U.S. and Canadian diplomats are expressing cautious optimism that a bilateral trade agreement between Washington and Ottawa could soon be reached, though they warn that President Donald Trump’s hefty tariffs are likely here to stay.
Speaking virtually to the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development on Monday, David Cohen, who served as the U.S. ambassador to Canada under former President Joe Biden, noted that the two nations were remarkably close to a deal before negotiations dramatically collapsed in August. Cohen stated that Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney made the right decision to walk away from the table at the eleventh hour.
Despite recent U.S. midterm elections delivering a rebuke to the Trump administration, Cohen cautioned that the Democrat-controlled Congress likely lacks the supermajority required to override a presidential veto on tariffs.
David MacNaughton, who served as Canada’s ambassador to Washington during Trump’s first term, echoed the need for realism. He advised the committee that the current negotiating environment is fundamentally different, and a return to the historic Canada-U.S. dynamic may be impossible. MacNaughton urged the Carney administration to continue pursuing a U.S. trade deal while actively diversifying trade partnerships and boosting domestic productivity.
Derek Burney, a former Canadian ambassador to the U.S. under Brian Mulroney, agreed with the diversification strategy,specifically pointing to Asia’s soaring demand for Canadian natural gas, oil, and critical minerals. Burney noted that Canada may be “wasting too much time” courting Europe, pointing out that nine European Union member states have still not ratified the existing Canada-EU free trade agreement.


