The U.S. State Department is privately providing asylum officers with internal assessments that portray parts of Mexico,Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador as safer than several major American cities. The internal narrative contrasts sharply with the department’s public travel advisories, which actively warn U.S. citizens of severe risks regarding violent crime, kidnapping, and terrorism in those exact regions.
According to internal documents reviewed by CNN, the reports suggest that migrants could safely relocate within their home countries rather than seeking refuge in the United States. For example, while the State Department publicly warns travelers against visiting the Gracias a Dios region of Honduras due to rampant crime, the internal memos provided to adjudicators describe the local crime rates as comparing favorably to certain U.S. metropolitan areas while downplaying human rights violations and extortion.
The rollout of these new assessments coincides with a dramatic spike in asylum rejections. Data from Syracuse University’s Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse indicates that 94% of asylum cases were denied in June, a staggering increase from approximately 50% just two years prior. Immigration experts, including Andrew Selee of the Migration Policy Institute, argue the new guidelines overlook critical systemic dangers, such as alleged police links to organized crime and the severe risks migrants face when attempting to relocate internally.
A State Department spokesperson defended the internal documents, stating they were prepared by regional experts to provide “useful background” for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services personnel and immigration judges evaluating protection claims. Administration officials maintain that public travel warnings are specifically tailored for American tourists and do not necessarily reflect the daily threat level faced by local residents in those countries.


