
Judge says Trump must answer questions in his own lawsuit
President Donald Trump will have to sit for a deposition in the $10 billion defamation lawsuit he filed against the British Broadcasting Corporation, after a federal judge rejected the idea that the presidency should shield him from the ordinary demands of civil litigation.
On November 17, U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz of the Southern District of Florida ordered Trump to appear for questioning by January 22, 2027. The revised deadline followed a joint request from Trump’s legal team and the BBC for additional time to exchange evidence and prepare for the next stages of the case.
“It is Trump’s case, so he should expect to be deposed,” Kuntz wrote in his order, according to reporting on the ruling.
The decision marks another setback for Trump’s efforts to postpone questioning in a lawsuit he initiated. The BBC had previously argued that the president’s legal team was delaying discovery and preventing the broadcaster from questioning the central figure in the dispute.
The dispute over Trump’s January 6 speech
Trump filed the lawsuit in December 2025, seeking $10 billion in damages over a BBC documentary that edited portions of his January 6, 2021, speech.
The documentary, part of the broadcaster’s Panorama series, combined remarks delivered at different points in the speech. The edit created the impression that Trump directly urged supporters to take violent action at the U.S. Capitol.
The BBC acknowledged that the editing was misleading and apologized. The broadcaster, however, denies that the documentary amounted to defamation or that it is legally liable for damages.
The controversy prompted a major internal crisis at the BBC, including the resignations of senior executives. Trump has argued that the documentary damaged his reputation and misrepresented his remarks.
The BBC maintains that it has a legal right to defend itself against the claims and to obtain evidence relevant to the president’s allegations.
Trump previously sought to postpone the deposition
The deposition dispute dates back several weeks. Magistrate Judge Enjolique Lett initially ordered Trump to appear by December 11, after the BBC complained that it had been unable to question him despite repeated attempts to schedule the session.
The BBC said the parties had previously agreed to an October 16 deposition, but Trump’s lawyers canceled it, citing a matter of national importance. The broadcaster argued that Trump was unavailable because of political activities, including a campaign appearance in Georgia.
Trump’s legal team disputed the BBC’s characterization. His attorneys said the president’s official responsibilities and security requirements created unusual scheduling challenges and denied that he was deliberately avoiding questioning.
The November 17 order gives both sides additional time. Trump must now be deposed by January 22, 2027, discovery must close by January 29, and both parties must be prepared for trial by May 3.
What the judge said about presidential responsibilities
Judge Kuntz acknowledged that the presidency deserves considerable respect and that courts should avoid imposing unnecessary burdens on a sitting president.
However, he also drew a distinction between burdens imposed on a president by outside parties and obligations arising from litigation the president voluntarily initiated.
The order referenced the Supreme Court’s 1997 decision in Clinton v. Jones, which established that a sitting president is not automatically immune from civil litigation involving conduct unrelated to official duties.
The judge’s reasoning underscores a basic principle of civil procedure: filing a lawsuit gives the plaintiff access to the courts, but it also carries obligations to participate in discovery and provide relevant evidence.
BBC seeks records tied to Trump’s reputation and damages
The deposition is only one part of the broader discovery dispute.
The BBC has also sought records concerning membership applications and fees at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort. The broadcaster argues that the information could help establish whether Trump suffered reputational damage, an important issue in determining potential damages in a defamation case.
Trump’s lawyers have challenged the requests, arguing that the president does not personally operate the club and that the records are not relevant to his claims.
The dispute illustrates how Trump’s decision to sue the BBC has opened aspects of his own business and public conduct to examination by the broadcaster’s lawyers.
Lawsuit survives, but not all of Trump’s claims
The deposition order comes after another significant development in the case.
On November 10, Judge Kuntz rejected the BBC’s attempt to dismiss Trump’s defamation claim, allowing that part of the lawsuit to proceed. However, the judge dismissed Trump’s separate claim under Florida’s unfair-business-practices law.
The ruling did not determine that the BBC committed defamation. It means only that Trump’s defamation allegations can continue through the legal process. The BBC continues to deny liability and says it will defend the case.
The next major milestone is Trump’s deposition, where BBC attorneys will have an opportunity to question him under oath about his claims and the alleged harm caused by the documentary.
The recording will be available initially only to attorneys involved in the case, rather than being released publicly.
A legal test for the president
The case presents an unusual situation: a sitting president is pursuing a multibillion-dollar lawsuit while facing questions about how much time and access he must provide to the opposing party.
Trump’s lawyers maintain that his presidential duties and security needs require special consideration. The BBC, meanwhile, argues that those responsibilities cannot eliminate its right to conduct meaningful discovery.
For now, the court has set a firm schedule. Whether the BBC can establish its defense—and whether Trump can prove the broadcaster’s editing caused legally compensable harm—will ultimately be decided through the litigation, not by the deposition order itself.

