Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan issued a sharp critique of the court’s conservative majority, asserting that several recent rulings have fundamentally weakened American democracy and fueled political polarization.
Speaking at Catholic University’s law school in Washington, D.C., the liberal justice took aim at decisions regarding voting rights, partisan gerrymandering, and campaign finance. Kagan argued that the court has “blinded itself to the very deleterious effects of their rulings on how the political system works.”
She specifically highlighted a pivotal 2019 decision that prohibited federal courts from intervening in extreme partisan gerrymandering, arguing that the ruling triggered a “race to the bottom” by both political parties, making a polarized country even more divided. Kagan also criticized recent decisions that narrowed protections under the Voting Rights Act and struck down campaign finance restrictions, validating the public’s view that the influence of immense financial resources in politics is a “nightmare.”
Despite her criticisms, Kagan dismissed the notion that the conservative majority simply acts as a rubber stamp for former President Donald Trump. She pointed out that the court has actively pushed back against him on several key issues,including mail-in ballots, tariffs, and birthright citizenship.


