
Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor recently stated that she hopes the court’s landmark 2024 decision granting former presidents broad criminal immunity will be overturned. Speaking at a civics education event at George Washington’s Mount Vernon estate over the weekend, Sotomayor candidly criticized some of her colleagues’ recent jurisprudence.
“I dissent a lot. I’m hoping that the court will take back some of the crazy things that it’s done,” Sotomayor told the audience. She quickly added, “I’m only joking — maybe not,” before specifically highlighting the 6-3 immunity ruling as one she hopes is reversed in her lifetime. Sotomayor vehemently dissented from that 2024 decision alongside Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, famously arguing at the time that the ruling effectively made the president a “king above the law”.
Beyond the specific ruling, the justice warned that the United States is currently experiencing a “rough patch” regarding the rule of law and civil discourse. “I don’t know how long it’s going to take to put us back on an even keel,” she noted. Acknowledging the anxiety many voters feel following the deeply consequential 2026 midterms, she praised the recent “outpouring of voters” as a necessary defense of democratic norms.
Despite her stark warnings, Sotomayor maintained a long-term optimism about American democracy and the judicial system. She predicted the Supreme Court would eventually “settle down” and establish a new, understandable order. Urging continued civic participation, the justice—who serves on the board of the education group iCivics—reminded attendees that “apathy is not acceptable”.

