Mamdani condemned the shooting in a statement Thursday, describing it as an “unconscionable and incredibly serious situation.” He said he had contacted Trump and would demand that the president halt ICE enforcement actions in New York City.
“I will not stand by while ICE agents terrorize our communities,” Mamdani said.
The mayor also called for federal immigration agents to leave city neighborhoods, hospitals and streets, arguing that the operation had endangered residents and heightened fear among immigrant communities.
Mamdani’s demand reflects a longstanding conflict between New York City’s sanctuary policies and the Trump administration’s efforts to expand immigration arrests and deportations. However, the mayor’s request does not itself give city officials the authority to terminate federal immigration operations.
What Happened in Marble Hill?
According to New York Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, the man was approached by federal officers during an ICE operation. At least one agent fired seven rounds, striking the 28-year-old man in the neck below his left ear, according to local reporting.
The man was identified as Oscar Belgal, a Dominican national. He was taken to NewYork-Presbyterian Allen Hospital for treatment. The child inside the vehicle was unharmed and was later placed in the care of a family member.
Tisch emphasized that the New York Police Department had not participated in the federal operation and that its officers were not present when the shooting occurred. NYPD personnel responded after hearing reports of gunfire and helped transport the wounded man for medical treatment.
Federal authorities said the operation targeted a Dominican national with a prior conviction for grand larceny and previous arrests involving other alleged offenses. The Department of Homeland Security did not publicly provide a detailed explanation for why the agent fired.
Dispute Over Federal Agents’ Tactics
The appearance of the officers also became a point of contention. Witnesses and city officials said some agents wore plain clothes, masks and construction-style vests, making it difficult for residents to identify them as law enforcement officers.
Mamdani questioned the tactics used during the arrest, particularly given the presence of a young child in the vehicle.
New York Governor Kathy Hochul also called for a full and transparent accounting of the incident. She said she had raised concerns with federal officials and urged the release of any available body-camera footage.
The central unanswered questions include what prompted the shooting, what threat the agent perceived and whether the use of force complied with federal policy. Those issues remain subject to investigation.
Mayor’s Effort to Secure the Man’s Release Fails
The confrontation continued after the shooting. Mamdani said he spoke with Trump and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin in an effort to secure the injured man’s release from federal custody.
According to the mayor’s account at a late-night press conference, those negotiations were unsuccessful. He said federal agents subsequently removed the man from the hospital in an unmarked vehicle.
It was not immediately clear where federal authorities took him. The development raised further questions for city officials about the man’s custody and access to medical care following the shooting.
Protests and Calls for Accountability
Several hundred people gathered near the shooting scene Thursday evening to protest the incident and broader immigration enforcement operations. Some demonstrators later moved toward the nearby hospital, where tensions increased as protesters attempted to block vehicles from leaving.
Law enforcement officers established barriers and moved people away from the hospital entrance.
Immigrant-rights advocates called for an immediate investigation, public release of available video and accountability if the agent used excessive force. Federal authorities have said the incident is under investigation.
The shooting also comes amid broader national scrutiny of ICE operations, including other high-profile shootings this year that have generated protests and renewed debate about federal enforcement tactics.
A New Flashpoint in the Sanctuary-City Dispute
New York City limits the circumstances in which its police force cooperates with federal immigration enforcement. The Trump administration has criticized sanctuary policies, arguing that they complicate efforts to detain and deport people accused or convicted of crimes.
City officials counter that aggressive federal operations can undermine community trust and public safety.
The Marble Hill shooting has brought those competing arguments into sharper focus. While federal authorities say the operation targeted a man with a criminal history, local leaders are demanding answers about the shooting itself, the presence of a child and the conduct of agents whose identities were not readily apparent to witnesses.
The investigation will determine the facts surrounding the use of force. In the meantime, Mamdani’s demand that ICE leave the city signals that the political confrontation over federal immigration enforcement is likely to continue.


