
An Ohio judge has dismissed Republican Rep. Max Miller’s defamation lawsuit against his former wife, Emily Moreno, concluding that allegations he doused her with hot water during a 2024 argument were “substantially true.”
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy issued the decision Monday, November 16, ruling that Miller failed to provide credible evidence supporting his claims that Moreno orchestrated media reports accusing him of domestic abuse.
The ruling represents a major legal defeat for the outgoing Ohio congressman, who had argued that the allegations were fabricated to damage his political reputation, undermine his reelection campaign and influence an ongoing custody dispute.
Kennedy also found no credible evidence that Moreno was responsible for leaking the allegations to the British tabloid Daily Mail or that she acted with actual malice, a key legal requirement in defamation cases involving public figures.
The judge dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice under Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, the state’s anti-SLAPP law designed to protect public-interest speech from retaliatory litigation. Miller was ordered to pay court costs and approximately $76,000 in Moreno’s attorney fees and expenses.
Audio recording becomes central to the ruling
One of the most significant elements in Kennedy’s decision was an audio recording of a conversation between Miller and Moreno concerning the June 2024 incident.
According to the court’s findings, Moreno confronted Miller about pouring hot water on her during an argument. Miller acknowledged that the incident occurred but characterized it as “horseplay in our kitchen” involving tap water.
Miller disputed Moreno’s account of the incident, particularly the allegation that he threw boiling water at her.
However, the judge concluded that the available evidence supported the essential substance of Moreno’s allegations.
In her written decision, Kennedy determined that Miller had not demonstrated that the statement concerning the hot-water incident was false.
The judge also considered photographs, police records and other documentation relating to the couple’s domestic dispute.
The distinction between the precise temperature of the water and the underlying allegation proved important. The court found that the central claim—that Miller had doused Moreno with hot water—was substantially true, even though the parties disputed aspects of how the incident happened.
Judge finds no evidence Moreno leaked the allegations
Miller filed his defamation lawsuit in May 2026, accusing Moreno, her divorce attorney and his law firm of helping spread damaging allegations through national media outlets.
His complaint focused on a Daily Mail report published earlier that month describing the alleged hot-water incident and other accusations of physical abuse.
Miller maintained that the reporting was false and intended to damage his reputation during an important election year.
Moreno denied communicating with the Daily Mail or arranging for anyone to provide information to the publication.
Her legal team argued that the allegations concerned the conduct of an elected public official and therefore involved matters of significant public interest.
Judge Kennedy found no credible evidence that Moreno had leaked the story, caused it to be published or acted with actual malice.
The ruling also noted that Miller himself had significantly amplified public attention surrounding the allegations through his own statements and legal filings.
Ohio’s anti-SLAPP law leads to dismissal
Moreno challenged the lawsuit under Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA), a state anti-SLAPP statute that took effect in April 2025.
Anti-SLAPP laws are designed to prevent powerful individuals from using expensive litigation to intimidate critics or suppress speech involving matters of public concern.
Her attorneys argued that allegations concerning the behavior of a sitting member of Congress deserved First Amendment protection and that Miller could not meet the legal standard required to establish defamation.
The court agreed, granting Moreno’s motion for expedited dismissal.
The ruling also carries financial consequences for Miller. In addition to dismissing the case with prejudice, Kennedy ordered him to cover approximately $76,000 in legal fees and costs incurred by Moreno.
Moreno’s attorney, Subodh Chandra, welcomed the decision, describing the lawsuit as an attempt to intimidate his client and silence speech concerning an elected official.
Miller’s legal team had not publicly provided an immediate response to the ruling.
Controversy extended beyond the defamation case
The lawsuit was part of a much broader and increasingly bitter legal dispute between Miller and Moreno, the daughter of Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio.
The couple married in August 2022 and separated in 2024. Their divorce and custody proceedings subsequently became the subject of national attention following allegations of domestic abuse.
Moreno has made additional allegations concerning incidents during their marriage, including claims involving a firearm and injuries to their daughter. Miller has denied the broader abuse allegations.
Authorities previously investigated allegations involving the couple’s daughter. According to Miller’s spokesperson, several allegations of child abuse were investigated by Cuyahoga County Division of Children and Family Services and deemed unsubstantiated.
The dispute has also generated separate litigation that remains unresolved.
The House Ethics Committee has been investigating Miller in connection with allegations surrounding his conduct, adding another layer of political and institutional scrutiny.
Miller loses reelection after political controversy
The court ruling comes after Miller suffered a significant political setback in Ohio’s 2026 midterm elections.
Miller lost his reelection campaign to Democrat Brian Poindexter by approximately 10 percentage points, despite representing a district that President Donald Trump carried in the 2024 presidential election.
The allegations and the highly publicized dispute with Moreno generated considerable political attention during the campaign.
Miller had previously been a prominent Trump ally. He worked on Trump’s 2016 and 2020 presidential campaigns and received the former president’s endorsement during his successful 2022 congressional campaign.
His political future is now uncertain following his electoral defeat and the latest court ruling.
What happens next?
The dismissal with prejudice means Miller cannot simply refile the same defamation claims against Moreno in the same case. However, the ruling may still be challenged through an appeal.
The decision also adds a significant development to the ongoing legal dispute between the former couple, particularly their separate custody-related proceedings.
For Moreno, the ruling represents a major legal victory. For Miller, it marks another setback following months of controversy, an unsuccessful reelection campaign and an ongoing ethics investigation.
The case also highlights the growing importance of anti-SLAPP protections in disputes involving public officials, media reporting and allegations of misconduct.

