A Pennsylvania man who fatally shot eight people—including seven of his own family members—before killing himself had a long history of exerting extreme authoritarian control over his relatives, keeping them isolated and managing their finances, authorities announced Thursday.
Investigators are still piecing together the exact motive that led 45-year-old Matthew Stone Sr. to gun down his wife, three of their children, two grandchildren, and two women who rushed to the Erie, Pennsylvania home during the October 9 massacre. However, a grim picture of domestic abuse and absolute control has begun to emerge.
During a news conference, Erie Police Chief Rick Lorah described a family living in isolated and filthy conditions. Lorah stated that Stone’s oppressive behavior began more than two decades ago when his wife became pregnant with their first child. The patriarch strictly monitored his family’s interactions with the outside world and kept a tight grip on their finances, even seizing the supplemental government income received for one of his grandchildren.
According to police records, Stone was arrested in 2019 and charged with threatening his wife with the exact same .40-caliber handgun he used in last week’s mass shooting. Those charges were ultimately withdrawn at a preliminary hearing after his wife, Michelle Stone, “changed her original statement,” Lorah said.
The tragedy was further compounded by revelations that one of the victims, Angelina Stone, was pregnant and actively planning to escape her father’s control. She had recently posted ultrasound photos of her unborn child to social media on September 25.
According to the police chief, Angelina had sent messages indicating she planned to leave the home immediately after giving birth and had disclosed that her father was physically abusive toward her brothers. When detectives processed the crime scene, they found boxes and bags fully packed inside Angelina’s bedroom.
The sole victim who was not related to the family was identified as a woman named Tanner, who rushed to the property as the violence unfolded.
As the horrifying details of the family’s living conditions come to light, local leaders are urging the community to evaluate how to better protect vulnerable residents.
“Were there opportunities to recognize that this family was struggling?” Erie Mayor Daria Devlin asked. “Were there places where our systems could have responded differently? And how do we make sure that families in this community who are suffering and struggling like this don’t fall through the cracks?”
“We cannot assume that any one intervention could have prevented what happened on Friday,” Devlin added. “But that can’t stop us from examining where each one of us can do better.”


