
Dozens of pro-Israel demonstrators braved the torrential rain and heavy winds of a late September nor’easter to protest outside the North American premiere of the documentary “NAZA” at the New York Film Festival.
The controversial film, directed by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, derives its title from the Hebrew military acronym for “collateral damage.” The documentary alleges that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) have systematically targeted Palestinian civilians during the ongoing war in Gaza. It recently won the Special Jury Prize at the Venice International Film Festival, despite the IDF explicitly rejecting the film’s allegations and questioning the unverified, anonymous military and intelligence sources featured within it.
The protest outside the sold-out screening at Lincoln Center was organized in part by the Israeli-American Council (IAC). Demonstrators arrived determined to provide what they argued was deliberately omitted context regarding the realities of urban warfare and the catalyst for the current conflict.
To counter the film’s narrative, organizers parked several trucks equipped with large LED screens outside the theater. The screens broadcast graphic footage from the October 7 massacre—titled “October 7: Bearing Witness to the Massacre”—alongside images of the hostages still held by Hamas in Gaza. The trucks prominently displayed the message: “Context is not censorship. It’s responsibility.”
Among the crowd standing in the driving rain were survivors of the Nova music festival massacre, including Rom El-Hai and Shalev Bitton, as well as Yunis Alkarnawi, a Bedouin Israeli who is credited with saving numerous lives during the October 7 terrorist attack.
“Movies have editors. History does not,” the IAC said in a statement regarding the demonstration. Activists and Jewish artists at the rally criticized the filmmakers for relying on anonymous testimony and failing to present a complete picture of the attack that initiated the war.
Inside the theater, the filmmakers acknowledged the protests. Abraham addressed the New York City audience, noting that while the October 7 attacks were horrific and unjustified, they could not justify the civilian death toll depicted in the documentary. Following its New York debut, the film is slated for additional screenings in the Hamptons, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Los Angeles as the anniversary of the October 7 attacks approaches.

