
The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday officially closed the door on attempts to revive a 2024 plea agreement that would have spared the accused mastermind behind the September 11 terrorist attacks from the death penalty.
The justices declined to hear an appeal brought by Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, cementing a prior appellate court ruling and leaving the high-profile Guantanamo Bay case on a precarious path toward trial.
The Canceled Agreements
The legal saga surrounding the plea agreements began two years ago when Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin abruptly revoked deals that had been brokered between military prosecutors and the defense.
The proposed agreements would have allowed Mohammed, alongside co-defendants Mustafa al-Hawsawi and Walid bin ‘Atash, to plead guilty in exchange for life sentences, entirely avoiding the possibility of capital punishment. In his decision to scrap the deals, Austin asserted that a decision of such monumental significance “should rest with me.”
The defense subsequently appealed Austin’s intervention, arguing it was unlawful. However, a D.C. Circuit panel backed the Defense Secretary’s authority to cancel the agreements in a 2-1 vote last year. By denying the current appeals without comment, the Supreme Court leaves that lower court ruling intact.
A Long and Complicated Path to Trial
With the plea deals officially dead, Mohammed and his co-defendants remain scheduled to face a military tribunal at the U.S. naval facility in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in June 2028. The death penalty will officially remain a possible punishment if they are convicted.
Despite the Supreme Court’s action clearing a major procedural hurdle, significant challenges remain ahead of the 2028 trial date. The proceedings have been plagued by years of legal gridlock, primarily driven by ongoing, fierce disputes regarding the admissibility of evidence obtained during the defendants’ time in CIA custody, where they were subjected to what the agency described as “enhanced interrogation techniques.”

