
The Supreme Court on Wednesday weighed how a decades-old privacy law designed to protect physical video rental records should be applied to modern internet tracking, a decision that could radically determine who has the standing to sue over the unauthorized sharing of their video viewing history.
The justices heard oral arguments regarding the 1988 Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA), attempting to determine if the law protects consumers who subscribe to any of a company’s products, or only those who specifically subscribe to its audiovisual offerings.
Congress initially enacted the VPPA in response to a high-profile scandal during the confirmation process of failed Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork, whose personal video rental history was leaked to the press. The law holds a “video tape service provider” liable for damages when it knowingly discloses a consumer’s personally identifiable information without written consent.
The current case stems from a 2022 class-action lawsuit brought against Paramount Global by Michael Salazar, a subscriber to a newsletter produced by 247Sports.com. The website, which serves as a hub for college sports and recruiting news, offers dozens of daily digital newsletters.
Salazar alleges that Paramount violated the VPPA by installing a Facebook tracking pixel on the website. This pixel allegedly allowed his data, including his video viewing history on the site, to be shared for targeted advertising without his explicit consent.
“These are not one-off disclosures,” Salazar’s lawyer, Joshua Hammack, told the court in his opening remarks. “They happen constantly, instantly every time someone, including a consumer, watches a video on the website... All [Paramount] needed to avoid liability was its consumer’s consent. Paramount just didn’t get it.”
The central legal issue hinges on whether Salazar fits the VPPA’s definition of a “consumer,” which the statute classifies as “any renter, purchaser, or subscriber of goods or services from a video tape service provider.” While Salazar argues the statute should be read broadly to apply to “any consumer,” several justices appeared highly skeptical of applying that interpretation to modern internet tracking.
“Would it not be natural to think goods or services from a videotape service provider would be video related services?” Justice Clarence Thomas asked early in the arguments.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson pressed Hammack to explain why Congress would have crafted the statute to categorize “consumer” so broadly. Hammack conceded there was “some mystery” to the varying definitions but argued the court should “live” with the text rather than attempting to rewrite the law.
Hypotheticals dominated the session, with the justices probing where the line should be drawn. Justice Amy Coney Barrett pointedly asked what specifically makes 247Sports a “video service provider,” while Justice Elena Kagan invoked a colorful scenario to illustrate the law’s original intent regarding embarrassment. Kagan theorized a situation where a judge might watch “some pretty funky sports videos... like a lot of women wrestling or something,” noting that preventing the disclosure of that embarrassing information is exactly why Congress passed the statute.
Paul Clement, representing Paramount Global, urged the justices to read the definition of consumer narrowly. He warned that accepting Salazar’s view could open the floodgates of litigation against almost any company with a website.
“When one refers to goods or services from a videotaped service provider, one does not logically refer to chicken sandwiches or dog bandanas,” Clement argued. “The alternative of interpreting the statute to create a veritable army of VPPA consumers without any personal information to protect, unless and until years or even decades later they watch a free video, has nothing to recommend it.”
Previously, a federal judge in Tennessee dismissed Salazar’s complaint, ruling that his newsletter subscription did not qualify him as a “consumer” under the VPPA because the newsletter was not an audiovisual material. A divided panel for the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals later affirmed that ruling, prompting Salazar’s appeal to the Supreme Court.
A final decision in the case is expected by the summer of 2027.

