A surrogate who defied a California couple’s request to abort the baby she was carrying has taken her fight to the U.S. Supreme Court, seeking to retain a voice in the infant’s medical care following a devastating prenatal diagnosis.
Attorneys for McKenna West, an Alaskan cardiac nurse, filed an emergency application asking Justice Elena Kagan to temporarily block a Los Angeles court ruling that declared the biological parents, Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, the sole legal parents of the child. Kagan handles emergency matters arising from the 9th Circuit, which includes California.
The legal war began after a 20-week ultrasound revealed the fetus had hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS), a rare and severe condition where the left side of the heart is underdeveloped. According to legal filings, Gilkar and Ahmed asked West to terminate the pregnancy, citing a provision in their surrogacy agreement covering serious fetal abnormalities.
West, however, refused to undergo the abortion. She reportedly offered to raise the child herself or arrange an adoption if the couple no longer wanted him, allowing them to walk away from any financial obligations. When the intended parents moved forward with legal action in California to establish their parental rights, West fled to Texas to give birth, arguing that the surrogacy agreement originally stipulated that disputes be handled in Alaska.
The baby—whom the biological parents named Rumi and West calls Gabriel—was born in Texas on August 12. Following his birth, he was quickly separated from West.
A Complex Legal and Ethical Dispute
A California court previously ruled in favor of Gilkar and Ahmed, determining that West had effectively consented to the court’s jurisdiction during earlier proceedings by submitting supporting documents. The ruling stripped West of any physical or legal custody, removing her ability to advocate for the baby’s medical needs or receive updates on his condition.
A Texas court recently dismissed West from the state proceedings and gave full faith and credit to the California judgment. West’s attorneys argue she was unlawfully dismissed and warn that without intervention, the child could be moved to California for hospice care rather than receiving life-saving surgeries.
“I’m fighting because this baby boy needs someone willing to advocate for and fight alongside him as he gets the ongoing treatment his fragile heart requires,” West stated in a recent op-ed.
Meanwhile, Gilkar and Ahmed have maintained that the baby is theirs and previously stated West violated the surrogacy contract. The infant underwent surgery shortly after birth and is reportedly in critical condition.
Justice Kagan has requested that the opposition respond to the appeal by 4 p.m. on September 18.


